MUSLIM HATE IN THAILAND

 

MUSLIM ANGER: THE THAI DILEMMA

by B.Raman

The internal security situation in southern Thailand, which has seen a recrudescence of long dormant Muslim anger against the Government since the beginning of this year, has again taken a turn for the worse with the death of six Muslims allegedly due to firing by the security forces outside a police station in the Narathiwat province on October 25,2004, and the subsequent death, allegedly due to suffocation and renal failure, of another 78 Muslims who were among those arrested during a large demonstration by about 3,000 Muslims outside the police station which led to the use of tear-smoke and firing by the security forces to disperse them.

2. The firing by the security forces and the consequent death of six Muslims, though tragic, are understandable taking into account the kind of provocative demonstration which the security forces faced. What is not understandable and needs to be strongly condemned, as it has been by many leading personalities and large sections of the media in Thailand itself, is the shocking treatment of the detenus after they had been arrested.

3. While only the enquiry ordered by the Government could establish the facts of the case, available evidence already suggests that the security forces cannot escape a major share of the blame for failing to protect those in their custody and for transporting them under apparently inhuman conditions packed like sardines in trucks which were too small for transporting such large numbers. The fact that while being transported, the detenus, many of them injured, had their hands allegedly tied behind their back and were made to lie one upon the other inside the trucks made the humanitarian disaster inevitable.

4. What has further aggravated the anger of not only the local Muslims, but also of many living in other countries of South-East Asia was the seeming insensitivity of Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra not only to the steadily deteriorating situation in Southern Thailand since January, but also to the humanitarian tragedy of October 25 and thereafter.

5. Right or wrong, there is a perception not only among the Muslims of Thailand and the region, but also among many non-Muslim intellectuals and human rights activists that his background as a policeman before he entered the world of business and then of politics has been coming in the way of a greater finesse in dealing with the situation and a willingness to hold the security forces in general and the police in particular accountable for their actions. Consequently, over-reaction against the Muslim anger resulting in excesses and human rights violations and a growing perception among the Muslims that the administration in general and the security forces in particular are anti-Muslim are adding to the complexities of an already complex situation.

6. The anger of the minorities in any country ---whether religious or sectarian or ethnic or ideological-- passes through the following stages--- communal, that is, against a community perceived as adversaries; anti-police/security forces due to their over-reaction and due to perceptions, right or wrong, that they are biased against the minorities; ant-Government due to perceptions that it is insensitive and over-protective of the security forces; and finally anti-national due to perceptions that the minorities cannot get justice as part of the existing nation.

7. A similar evolution has been taking place in Southern Thailand. The failure of the Government to lucidly analyse the situation and follow an appropriate strategy to tackle it has played into the hands of jihadi terrorist organisations/elements of external inspiration/instigation and Thailand faces the danger of a situation similar to that prevalent in the Southern Philippines. The fact that Thailand had faced a similar Muslim insurgent movement in its Southern provinces in the past and dealt with it successfully should not lead to a feeling of complacency that it could ultimately deal successfully with the present situation too without its threatening national integrity, economic stability and national security.

8. Pernicious ideas of pan-Islamic kind emanating from organisations such as Osama bin Laden's Al Qaeda and his International Islamic Front (IIF) were not there in the 1980s despite the then raging jihad against the Soviet troops in Afghanistan. Today, such pernicious ideas have been creeping across the South and the South-East Asian region from their spawning grounds in Pakistan and Bangladesh. They make the tasks of the security forces much more difficult than they were in the past.

9. There are five characteristic features of the situation in Southern Thailand as it has evolved since January,2004:

 

Insurgency still rages in southern Thailand

By Paris Lord, Agence France-Presse

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

BANGKOK: Two years after suspected Muslim militants raided an army base in southern Thailand and set off a bloody insurgency, the region is driven by distrust and peace remains a distant prospect, analysts say.

A daily tide of violence in the Muslim-majority provinces bordering Malaysia has left more than 1,000 people dead since the January 4, 2004, raid, and critics say government efforts to rein in the violence have been woeful.

Bangkok has tried dumping 120 million paper birds from aircraft in a symbolic peace drop and pledging cable television for village teahouses as part of efforts to bring peace.

But despite repeated government assurances that the unrest is under control or declining, the frequent killings—two men were found shot and beheaded on Monday—suggest otherwise.

It appeared an end to the violence was a long way off, said Sunai Phasuk, Human Rights Watch consultant on Thailand.

“Until now, the militants haven’t identified themselves or made clear their objectives and that in itself indicates they don’t have any intention to start negotiations with the government,” he told AFP.

“We’re talking about a double failure.

“We know the government can’t solve the militants [problem], the second is the government can’t win the trust of the locals,” said Sunai, blaming officials for abuses which started with the investigation into the original January 4 raid.

Former Prime Minister Anand Panyarachun, whom Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra tapped in February to run the government-appointed National Reconciliation Commission, has said Bangkok must admit and apologize for past abuses.

When Anand was appointed to the commission and charged with devising a peace plan, the death toll stood at around 610. It is expected to publish its recommendations in March.

The restive provinces once formed an autonomous Muslim sultanate until they was annexed by Thailand a century ago. Separatist violence has periodically flared since then, but the groups who led the last campaign in the 1970s largely disintegrated in the 1980s and many members are in exile.

Abdul, a villager in Narathiwat province who asked his full name not be used because of fears for his safety, said government officials had failed to build unity and peace over the past two years.

He said the main reason was the officials, who are all Buddhists, lacked understanding of the roots of the problems and Thai Muslims’ ways of life.

Buddhists form the majority in this country of about 63 million people. Muslims make up fewer than five percent and most of whom live in southern Thailand. Many Muslims are ethnic Malays who speak Yawi or Malayu dialects, not Thai.

A controversial emergency decree the government introduced in July 2005 and renewed for an extra three months in October allows detention without trial and gives officials immunity from prosecution.

“While the decree gives more power to state officials to arrest and detain suspects, it has failed to regain the trust of local people toward the government and somehow made it worse,” Abdul said.

The head of Pattani’s local administration, Ahmad Somboon Bualuang, said he could not see any improvement in the situation.

Instead, economic conditions had deteriorated, with incomes cut to around one third of what they were before 2004, because people were afraid of leaving their homes and tourism had crashed.

“I haven’t seen any improvement over the past two years, even though the government has tried to present positive images about what’s going on,” he said.

“In fact, local people feel more pressure as the authorities cannot explain clearly who is actually behind the violence, and they’ve arrested a number of people who haven’t done anything wrong,” Ahmad added.

Deputy Prime Minister Chidchai Vanasatidya said on Sunday the government would work harder to end the violence.

“Officials do not really understand the problem clearly and they haven’t implemented follow-up measures,” Chidchai conceded. “Lots of things have to be done.”

 

Thailand admits southern Muslim violence raging unabated

The Associated Press

June 21, 2007

KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia: Southern Thailand's Islamic insurgency has not abated despite the new government's peace efforts, the defense minister acknowledged Thursday, though he claimed the extremists were on their "last legs."

The government, which took over after a military coup late last year, says it is seeking talks with the rebels and has adopted a "hearts and minds" approach to ending the insurgency, reversing former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra's hard-line military bid to crush the rebellion.

However, the rebels have only intensified their violence in Thailand's three southernmost provinces, the only Muslim-dominated areas in the Buddhist-majority country.

The violence has killed more than 2,300 people since early 2004 in the south, where many Muslims have long complained of discrimination.

"The violence in the southern border provinces seems, at the moment, not getting better due to the nature of the culprits themselves," Thai Defense Minister Gen. Boonrod Somtad said during a visit to Malaysia's biggest city, Kuala Lumpur.

But the "instigators ... seem to be on the last legs, on the point of trying to elevate the problem, trying to make the problem more international," Boonrod said through an interpreter. He did not elaborate.

The insurgency-hit area lies near Thailand's border with Muslim-majority Malaysia.

Boonrod also said that, even though the military-established Thai government is a temporary one, it was trying to enact new measures to solve the problem by using reconciliation policies.

"Now our policies are coming into effect, and the situation in the south should be improving in the foreseeable future," he said.

Speaking at a news conference alongside Boonrod, Malaysia's Deputy Prime Minister Najib Razak expressed confidence that Thai authorities will be able to find a peaceful solution, and that the unrest would not spill into the bordering parts of northern Malaysia.

"We have taken the stance that this is a domestic problem of Thailand, and therefore we respect the sovereignty of Thailand and we will not interfere unless we are invited to cooperate and to help out in any way," Najib said.

 

Thailand's south derides ceasefire claim as hoax

July 18, 2008

YALA, Thailand (AFP) — Televised claims of a ceasefire by separatist militants were derided Friday as a hoax in Thailand's Muslim-majority south, after a veteran insurgent leader disavowed the move.

A group called Ruam Pak Tai Khong Prathet Thai (Thailand's United Southern Underground group) made a videotaped announcement Thursday, broadcast on an army-run television station, declaring an end to the violence.

The declaration was greeted with widespread doubts among the Thai military, other insurgent leaders, and residents of the southern region along the Malaysian border who have suffered through four years of near-daily attacks.

Thailand's army commander General Anupong Paojinda said the military was surprised by the announcement, and an official statement later distanced the army further from the ex-army chief who had apparently negotiated the move.

General Chetta Thanacharo, also the former defence minister, claimed he had orchestrated a ceasefire.

"The royal Thai army has nothing to do with the announcement by the militant group on Thai television. It was carried out by a private person, General Chetta, who hopes for peace in the southern provinces," the statement said.

"The Thai army continue to adhere to a policy of non-violence and strict law enforcement to solve the problems in the south and to create justice along with development and security for local residents," it said.

Hours after Thursday's televised statement, leaflets written in Thai and Arabic began circulating the restive town of Yala, urging militants to continue their armed struggle and to ignore the ceasefire announcement.

Residents said they saw no reason to believe the declaration.

"I don't give any weight to yesterday's announcement. I closely monitor developments and I don't think it was genuine," said Ahmad Jaewae, 45, an Internet shop owner in Yala town.

"The real leader would speak from his heart, not from a script," he told AFP.

Torlab Sama-ali, 60, a rubber tapper in Yala, was also skeptical but said he hoped for official negotiations between the government and militants to stop the violence.

"If it's true it would be very welcome, as we are all suffering from the unrest -- and as Muslims we do not agree with violence," he said.

Paison, 28, who gave only one name, said the professed leaders were former militants who are no longer active.

"I am not convinced that a ceasefire would be agreed this easily without any concessions after all the many Muslims arrested over the years," he said.

The conflict has claimed 3,300 lives in the past four years and authorities have struggled to identify the militants, who rarely claim responsibility for attacks.

One veteran militant leader, Kasturi Mahkota, disavowed the statement, saying his group knew nothing about the militants who appeared on television.

"Nothing has changed and the dialogue with the Thai authorities is still in the pipeline," Kasturi, foreign affairs chief for the Patani United Liberation Organisation (PULO), told The Nation newspaper.

PULO emerged in 1968 and over the next two decades became the biggest insurgent group fighting in the mainly Muslim region along the southern border with Malaysia.

The group largely fell apart in the 1990s with most of their leaders living in exile. Past statements by PULO and Kasturi have had little effect on the fighting on the ground.

Analysts from local human rights organisation Working Group on Justice for Peace said the announcement could do more harm than good.

"The announcement was just a scene in a play. It not only contributes to the situation of unrest but will worsen the situation," the group said in a statement.

In their video, the militants said the ceasefire had taken effect from July 14. But attacks have continued to rattle the region since then, including bombings at two of the main police stations in the border provinces.

The region was an autonomous Malay Muslim sultanate until Thailand annexed it in 1902, provoking decades of tension.

 

 

MAIN INDEX

BIBLE INDEX

HINDU INDEX

MUSLIM INDEX

MORMON INDEX

BUDDHISM INDEX

BAPTISMAL INDEX

WORD FAITH INDEX

AMILLENNIAL INDEX

WATCHTOWER INDEX

MISCELLANEOUS INDEX